Was Jesus a great moral teacher?

In Mere Christianity, Christian thinker C.S. Lewis argued that you cannot regard Jesus as a moral teacher if you deny his divinity.

A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic—on the level with the man who says he is a poached egg—or else he would be the Devil of Hell. You must make your choice. Either this man was, and is, the Son of God: or else a madman or something worse. [Emphasis added]

Informed by Lewis’ so-called “Lunatic, Liar, or Lord” trilemma, atheist filmmaker Peter Breinholt produced a short documentary “Madman or Something Worse.” Breinholt contends that most of Jesus’ moral contributions were not original, and that most of his original contributions were not moral.

Here is part 1 of the film:

Continue reading

Miss USA contestants on evolution and education

The Miss USA competition is evidence that our culture celebrates beauty over brains. Now, that isn’t to say these women aren’t smart per se. All I mean to suggest is that they needn’t sound intelligent to win the pageant. Consider, for example, the contestants’ answers when asked whether evolution should be taught in public schools:

Their answers were, for the most part, woefully (and unashamedly) ignorant. (You can watch every contestant’s answer here.) Several contestants, perhaps wanting to avoid a Carrie Prejean-like controversy, answered that both religion and evolution should be taught in schools. Both should be taught in schools, but not in a science class where students may confuse creationism for an alternative scientific theory to evolution. Religious ideas about the origin and evolution of life should be discussed in philosophy or religious studies courses.

Worse still, of the 51 contestants, only two “unequivocally support[ed]” evolution. Thankfully one of those two was crowned Miss USA: California’s Alyssa Campanella. Here was her response:

I was taught evolution in high school. I do believe in it. I’m a huge science geek. [...] I like to believe in the big bang theory and, you know, the evolution of humans throughout time.

Alexis Tate benefit concert

Some SHAFT readers may know Dan Tate, a USU philosophy major. Dan’s a great guy, and on Thursday we have a chance to do him a favor. There will be a benefit concert for his wife Alexis on Thursday, June 23rd, at 7:30 PM at St. John’s Episcopal Church. She has a chronic case of Lyme disease, and this concert will help Dan and Alexis afford the treatments. Below is a poster with more information.

My Testimony: A Response to Bruce D. Porter.

Last fall in one of my graduate seminars we were discussing a reading by a scholar by the name of Bruce D. Porter who was a respected, published scholar from BYU in political science and international affairs. My professor remarked that he didn’t know what had happened to Porter because he had stopped publishing and “disappeared”; well apparently Bruce D. Porter is an LDS general authority these days in the Quorum of the Seventy. In the June issue of The Ensign (a monthly magazine of the LDS Church containing talks, columns, and stories from church leaders that members are encouraged to read as part of their regular scripture study) Porter has an article entitled “Defending the Family in a Troubled World.”

It is not surprising that a man who has a PhD in political science from Harvard and who built his career as a researcher and professor in that field would have opinions on one of the most pressing social and political issues of this generation. And let me be clear, my purpose here is not to, as some have written, contend that the article in the Ensign was in poor taste or out of place for a publication that some members believe to be modern scripture. Porter is entitled to voice his opinions whether I agree with them or not.

My purpose is to confront the CONTENT of what was said. Porter is a smart man who, regardless of what he says over any pulpit or in any religious publication, truly knows that by exercising his right to free speech and free expression he is not free from critique by those who exercise their free speech with opposing views and that such critiques do not constitute any form of bigotry or persecution—for he built his career in a field (academia) that does not survive without critique.

Continue reading

“The Book of Mormon” sweeps the Tony Awards

Sunday night, “The Book of Mormon” Broadway musical swept the Tony Awards, as expected. Of its 14 nominations, it ultimately won 9 Tonys, including best musical, score, book, direction and featured actress. When the musical’s creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker (of South Park fame) accepted the awards last night, they thanked Joseph Smith. “He couldn’t be here tonight,” they joked, “but—you did it, Joseph! You got the Tony!”

Andrew Rannells sang “I Believe”, probably the least profane song from “The Book of Mormon.” The performance was the highlight of the Tonys. Enjoy.

Link bomb #20

A history of the LDS garment. Another interesting history is the evolution of the LDS prayer circle.

What a religious debate on Facebook would look like in the Mayan pre-Columbian America.

Sincere devoutness is sometimes indistinguishable from good satire. Case in point: this Stake President’s blog. I hope it’s a spoof, and I’m pretty sure it is. But wow, it’s a very convincing parody—and funny! My favorite post is his awkward and euphemistic discussion of oral sex. [Edit: I initially thought this was real, but some commenters convinced me otherwise.]

The Scientific American on why we’re suckers for stories of our own demise.

The Vatican released a strongly-worded report demanding decisive and dramatic action to curb the effects of global climate change. The Vatican also invited AIDS experts for a two-day symposium to discuss prevention methods, including condoms.

The Catholic Church has received incredibly negative press due to the priest abuse scandal (which is still developing). But I think the Catholic Church is due some credit for tackling substantive issues like global warming, poverty, etc. One of my long-standing complaints about the LDS Church is its focus on relatively petty concerns (double piercings and flip-flops come to mind).

It’s time to reconsider graduation prayer in public high schools, writes Bruce Ledewitz for Religion Dispatches.

Greta Christina argues that all religious are equally crazy. I maintain that some religions are demonstrably more implausible than others, but I agree that religious folks should be slow to find the crazy in other religions lest they forget the crazy in their own.

It’s easy to mock Harold Camping’s failed prediction that the rapture would occur on May 21st (Camping has rescheduled the rapture for October). But Jesus was also a failed doomsday prophet, and Joseph Smith believed that the Second Coming would happen in 1890 or 1891.

A survey of nearly 15,000 people suggests that atheists have the best sex lives. Perhaps were there more atheists in Utah, it wouldn’t be the most stressed state. Relatedly, the US reports far lower levels of happiness than similarly developed but more secular nations.

MRI tests reveal that Apple triggers a religious reaction in its fans’ brains. I wrote about a similar study last summer.

An Islamic theologian and scholar says the Prophet Muhammad probably never existed.

Santa Monica residents may vote on a ballot initiative in November 2012 that would ban circumcision.

I saw a Craiglist job ad for Java engineers that was restricted to LDS applicants only. It specified further that the applicant must be temple-worthy. Unless the job posting is with the church directly, isn’t this illegal?

Nearly two-thirds of Americans now support legalizing same-sex relations, a new record high.

The top 10 myths about the brain.

Some drama in the Reddit Exmormon community: A poster is threatened by another member with being publicly outed as ex-Mormon for not being pro-gay enough.

The Mormon Chronicle writes that the public education system is antithetical to LDS teachings, and that Mormons must only be taught by other Mormons.

The far right has lionized Ayn Rand for decades, and Republicans are again giving her a lot of lip-service. What a strange bedfellow Rand makes for the Religious Right though, given how virulently anti-Christian she was.

A Saudi woman is arrested after campaigning for the right to drive.

French postmodern philosopher Jacques Derrida becomes an internet meme.

Despite the church’s past with polygamy and its entrenched, traditional gender roles, there is a feminist strain within the Mormon tradition—one that may be enjoying a resurgence. The Salt Lake Tribune recently published a piece about Mormon women’s historical ability to administer priesthood blessings. And Mormon blogger Joanna Brooks suggests that the LDS concept of Heavenly Mother may be making a comeback.

Why people stick by scandal-plagued pastors.

Sam Harris sketches out a morality without free will and its implications.

Philosophy professor Andrew Fisher of the University of Nottingham contends that philosophy needs to be taught much earlier. He has started teaching at primary schools in disadvantaged areas, teaching kids the fundamentals of logic and critical thinking.

Seventy percent of science award finalists are the children of immigrants, showing that immigration is a boon to science and math.

I’ve written at length about BYU’s use of aversive therapies (including shock therapy) in its treatment of homosexuality. In the interest of fairness, I’d like to share a more sympathetic view of this part of BYU history.

A recent neurological study finds that powerful religious experiences may actually contribute to atrophy in the brain.

A radical new birth control injection for men promises to be 100% effective for 10 years. What’s more, it has no reported side effects and is completely and quickly reversible.

How to argue on the internet.

After his mom won the lottery, an atheist converts to Christianity. Fox carries the story as ‘news’.

CNN compiles a list of popular Bible misattributions—phrases and ideas people think are in the Bible, but are not.

Is atheism just a ‘sexed-up’ version of agnosticism, or are the two terms distinct? And if the latter, are they complimentary or incompatible? Talking Philosophy analyzes the competing definitions.

Newsweek calls 2011 ‘the Mormon Moment’. Two presidential candidates belong to the faith, the Senate leader Harry Reid is Mormon, and Mormonism is the subject of a critically-acclaimed Broadway musical.

The latest presidential election poll has Mitt Romney as the Republican frontrunner, with most not caring about his Mormonism.

BYU Studies identifies the many LDS themes in Stephanie Meyer’s Twilight saga.

Richard Dawkins and 13 other academics launch a new private humanities college.

Skeptic Mormon shares some troubling facts about Mormon polygamy and debunks popular myths about the practice.

American filmmaker Vikram Gandhi made up a guru character and a phony religion, then filmed a documentary as he developed a following. The documentary illustrates just how credulous our species can be.