The other day, I was re-evaluating my views on the separation of church and state and a crazy idea occurred to me—a revelation, if you will. Were we to deny the tax exemptions that religions currently enjoy, we should also lift their political prohibitions.
The reason we are currently able to preclude religions from substantial political lobbying and partisan electioneering is because they are tax-exempt. Absent that tax-exemption, how can we justify denying them the First Amendment rights we afford to other special interests and (especially now, after Citizens United case) corporations? Taxation requires representation—that’s a quintessential American belief.
Don’t get me wrong. I think increased religious involvement in politics would, for the most part, be bad. But that I disagree with religions’ agendas hardly warrants their disenfranchisement (again, assuming we tax them).
This is an uncomfortable position for a secularist, and I’m not yet fully convinced of it. What do you think of the argument I briefly sketched out?